First up was Simplicity 1541, which is a basic straight skirt:
I've been meaning to try this one, not only for it's basic style, but also because it is part of Simplicity's "Amazing Fit" line and I wanted to find out if it was really "amazing". It also allowed me to use my leftover pink denim that I used for my latest incarnation of the Gertie pants. I made view B, the middle length version.
One of the features of the pattern is that is allows different pattern pieces for different figures: the choices are slim, average, and curvy. Sort of the same concept as cup sizes for the bust that many patterns have these days. And the pattern sheet provides detailed instructions to determine what you are, but let me save you time: if you have less than 10 inches between your waist and hip measurements, you are slim; if you are 10 inches you are average; and if you are more than 10 inches you are "curvy".
More helpfully, the pattern provides detailed hip finished garment measurements for each size and each "fit". This allowed me to determine that, unlike most Big Four patterns, there wasn't a lot of ease in this skirt. My measurements put me as size 14, and since there are 10 inches between my waist and hip (depending on whether I've eaten pizza or not), I am "average", not surprisingly (I have pretty standard figure). The finished hip garment measurements for a size 14 average is 39, which seemed too tight, since that is my exact hip measurement, but this pattern is drafted with 1 inch side seam allowances for better fitting.
I went with it. The instructions seemed to create more work than necessary, but I reminded myself that I'm trying to do things new ways with new techniques so I don't get bored, so I did it their way. You are instructed to baste the front yoke to the front of the skirt, and then baste the back yokes to the backs of the skirt, and then baste the side seams with a 1 inch seam and try it on.
My skirt was tight, like indecently tight. The pattern instructions have all kinds of fitting tips, like what to do if you side seam pulls to the front or to the back, but my side seams were completely straight, the thing was just too tight. The instructions tell you pull out some of your basting stitches and pin until you get a straight seam, but I couldn't remove the side seams while standing in it, so I eyeballed it and decided the whole thing would fit better if I used 3/4 seams instead of 1 inch, thus giving me 1 inch more of ease in the skirt.
I basted the 3/4 inch side seam, and then removed the 1 inch seam and tried it on. Very good fit. But of course, by doing it this way, I then had to remove the 3/4 basted side seam, and remove the yokes from the skirt, sew the front and back yokes together for real, and then sew the side seams for real this time, using the 3/4 inch seam allowance. Then attach the yokes to the skirt. Whew. A lot of work for a simple skirt:
Once I got it all done, though, with the yoke facings and zipper and everything, the waist felt a little loose. Grrrr. Did my waist stretch while putting in the yoke facing? Was it the lycra in the denim? I don't know, which just goes to show, no matter how much you fit as you sew you never really know until you are done, done, done.
I made the front seams a mock felled seam since I have been doing that on my jeans muslins:
The inside view of the mock felled seam:
And I put in my first lapped zipper, which I've never done before, but again, I'm trying new things so I don't get bored:
A pretty good first effort, but I'm not convinced of its superiority to the centered zipper.
The skirt has a back kick pleat:
All in all, I'm very pleased with this skirt (its an excellent work skirt) although next time I might try a 7/8 inch side seam and see how that works. I think it depends on your fabric and its stretch, so I won't know until I make it.
Next up was Vogue 1247:
Where have I been? This pattern was named one of the top 10 patterns of 2011, I think, but I was totally oblivious. Everyone on the interwebs seems to love, love, love this skirt, with the front in-seam pockets, although most sewers are adding 5 to 8 inches to the length. As drafted it finishes 15 inches long. Which is fine if you are a teenager, not so good if you are over 45 years old.
I knew I wanted to make this in a soft cotton twill - the kind you would use to make a great pair of chinos. I knew I also wanted to make this skirt so I could wear it at the beach, so I chose a soft grayish blue (or a soft bluish gray, I can't tell) from fashionfabricsclub.comhttp://www.fashionfabricsclub.com/p710_12372-sea-glass-blue-twill. The color reminds me of bleached-from-the-sun beachwood.
I made a size 14 but added 5 inches as I figured 20 inches was a good length on a summer beach skirt. I didn't add the length to the pattern pieces; I just chalked it out on the fabric since it was a pretty straight forward alteration.
Here's the hands-in-the-pockets obligatory photo that everyone who has made this skirt has posted:
And the back:
A lot of the sewers who made this skirt have made multiples, but strangely, I don't feel the urge, even though I ordered another cotton twill in anticipation that I would want to. I might make this in corduroy or wool come this fall, adding another couple inches. We'll see.
Vogue has a reputation of being slightly more difficult that the other Big Four, and I admit that while this is a simple skirt, more than once I had to think about how things went together, and not every little step is illustrated in the instructions. But there was nothing anyone will some sewing experience couldn't figure out.
More on the jeans project to follow, but that's all for now!
Parting Shot: The Carpenter and some of his brothers before we were evacuated from the island due to Hurricane Arthur: